Film Review: M*A*S*H (1970)

Robert Altman, a luminary of the New Hollywood movement, cemented his reputation with M.A.S.H (1970), a darkly comedic war film that defied conventional studio norms. While the film remains Altman’s most commercially successful work—grossing $81 million globally and becoming the third highest-grossing film of 1970 —it occupies an ambivalent position in his oeuvre. Critics often prioritise his later, more experimental works like Nashville (1975) or The Long Goodbye (1973) as superior artistic achievements. This discrepancy, however, stems less from M.A.S.H’s flaws and more from its cultural commodification: the film’s raw irreverence was overshadowed by the gentler, long-running television adaptation (1972–1983), which diluted its edge for mainstream palatability. Altman himself distanced from the sitcom, lamenting its sentimentalisation of his anarchic vision. Yet, M.A.S.H remains a vital artefact of New Hollywood’s anti-establishment ethos, blending satire with formal innovation.

The film adapts H. Richard Hornberger’s 1968 novel MASH: A Novel About Three Army Doctors, penned under the pseudonym Richard Hooker. Hornberger, a former US Army surgeon during the Korean War, infused the text with autobiographical grit, chronicling the absurdity and trauma of frontline medical service . While the novel’s episodic structure and dark humour provided a blueprint, Altman and screenwriter Ring Lardner Jr. expanded its scope, transforming it into a scathing allegory for contemporary American disillusionment. Hornberger’s disdain for military bureaucracy and his colleagues’ coping mechanisms—pranks, hedonism, and sardonic detachment—resonate throughout the film, though Altman’s interpretation amplified its anti-war fervour.

Set in the 4077th Mobile Army Surgical Hospital (MASH) during the Korean War, the film follows Captain “Hawkeye” Pierce (played by Donald Sutherland), a sardonic surgeon transferred to the unit alongside Captain “Duke” Forrest (played by Tom Skerritt). Their hedonistic camaraderie—drinking, gambling, and bedding nurses—serves as a coping mechanism against the horrors of war . Joined by Captain “Trapper” McIntyre (played by Elliott Gould), the trio’s antics clash with the puritanical Major Frank Burns (played by Robert Duvall) and disciplinarian nurse Major Margaret “Hot Lips” Houlihan (played by Sally Kellerman), whom they torment through elaborate pranks, including wiretapping her intimate encounters and exposing her in a shower. The film’s episodic structure mirrors the erratic rhythms of wartime: frenetic surgery scenes, punctuated by lulls filled with mischief, reflect the characters’ psychological fraying . Lieutenant Colonel Henry Blake (played by Roger Bowen), their permissive commander, embodies the military’s institutional absurdity, prioritising survival over decorum.

Though ostensibly about Korea, M.A.S.H’s subtext screamed Vietnam. Released in 1970, amid escalating anti-war protests, the film’s anachronistic 1960s hairstyles, slang, and attitudes—Hawkeye’s hippie-esque insouciance, the mockery of authority—rendered it a thinly veiled critique of contemporary militarism . Altman weaponised irreverence to skewer not just the military but organised religion (e.g., the blasphemous “Last Supper” scene where a dentist fakes suicide) and bureaucratic hypocrisy . This resonated with Baby Boomers, whose distrust of institutions mirrored the film’s anarchic spirit.

For screenwriter Ring Lardner Jr.—a member of the Hollywood Ten blacklisted during McCarthyism—M.A.S.H was both a creative triumph and political vindication. Lardner, who spent a year in prison for refusing to name Communists to HUAC, infused the script with anti-authoritarian venom, framing the military as a microcosm of oppressive systems. His Oscar win for Best Adapted Screenplay (1971) marked a symbolic defeat for the establishment that had ostracised him, though Altman’s improvisational direction often overshadowed Lardner’s contributions. Nevertheless, the script’s blend of absurdity and pathos—epitomised by the mock-suicide scene—anchored the film’s tonal balance.

Altman’s direction, though less overtly experimental than in later works, established his trademark style. The use of overlapping dialogue—actors speaking simultaneously to mimic real-life chaos—immersed viewers in the MASH unit’s bedlam. Long zooms and a mobile camera (pioneered by cinematographer Harold E. Stine) heightened the documentary realism, while episodic pacing mirrored the characters’ fractured existence. Modern audiences may find the structure disorienting initially, but its rhythm coalesces into biting satire, exemplified by set pieces like the football game rigged with “legal cheating” or the infamous shower prank .

Johnny Mandel’s score, though largely forgettable, is immortalised by the theme song “Suicide Is Painless.” Penned by Altman’s 14-year-old son, Michael, its melancholic lyrics (“Through early morning fog I see / Visions of the things to be”) juxtapose the film’s frenetic comedy with existential despair . The song’s inclusion during the faux-suicide scene—where dentist “Painless” Waldowski (played by John Schuck) considers euthanasia—underscores the characters’ precarious mental states, blending farce with tragedy .

Paradoxically, M.A.S.H’s cultural footprint was eclipsed by its television adaptation. Premiering in 1972, the sitcom softened the film’s edges: Alan Alda’s Hawkeye became more empathetic, Major Burns was replaced by the nuanced Charles Winchester, and storylines leaned into sentimentality. The series finale in 1983 drew 106 million viewers, a record unbroken for 27 years, cementing its place in nostalgia. By contrast, Altman’s film, with its unapologetic misanthropy and graphic surgery scenes, aged into a “raw” relic of Vietnam-era anger, its relevance fading as the war receded from memory.

Contemporary critiques often condemn the film’s treatment of women. Major Houlihan is reduced to a sexualised punchline—her humiliation in the shower scene epitomises the era’s casual misogyny. Nurses are objectified, and female characters lack agency, reflecting 1970s Hollywood’s gender biases. While some defend this as period-accurate satire, others argue it reinforces regressive tropes. Altman’s refusal to moralise his protagonists’ behaviour—Hawkeye’s womanising is framed as roguish charm—further complicates its legacy.

Despite its flaws, M.A.S.H endures as a caustic masterpiece. Its themes—the absurdity of war, institutional incompetence, and humour as psychological armour—remain tragically pertinent. In an era of renewed global conflict and authoritarian resurgence, Hawkeye’s defiant irreverence feels newly urgent. The film’s refusal to offer tidy resolutions or redemptive arcs mirrors the unresolved chaos of real-world geopolitics. As Roger Ebert observed, “We laugh, that we may not cry”. Altman’s M.A.S.H, raw and unrepentant, ensures the laughter is laced with unease—a testament to its enduring power.

RATING: 7/10 (+++)

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo

Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9

Posted Using INLEO